The girls had:
Tapioca pudding as we thought the tapioca sort of looked like little butterfly eggs.
Cottage cheese eggs on a spinach leaf.
Fruit-kabob caterpillars (blueberries and grape slices)
Carrot slice caterpillar
Crescent roll chrysalis (we filled it with an apple piece shaped like a caterpillar).
Peanut butter and jelly sandwich cut in half diagonally and shaped like a butterfly with orange bell pepper antennae.
Close up of the "eggs"
Close up of one caterpillar
and the other caterpillars
Close up of the chrysalis
You can see how we made the chrysalises here.
And the butterfly
Harold had cottage cheese, diced apples, blueberries and grapes, peanut butter and jelly sandwich cut into 4 triangles and his chrysalis.